A couple of questions:
1. What does the pedal feel like? Firm? Squishy?
Very very squishy... there is about 1/4 push of play until it starts braking.
2. What braking performance do you have? Vibration? Pulling to one side? Squeaking/squealing?
No Vibration, sometimes a little pull, and a ton of squeaking... it stops squeaking if I starts braking.
3. When backing up (after a forward motion stop), does the clunking/rattling only happen once, i.e. if you stopped and then continued reversing and stopped again, do the above noises repeat?
If I go in reverse and brake it rattles, If I let go of the brake and keep going it rattles and clunks
4. How old are the rotors? Have you verified minimum specified thickness?
Rotors are Original about 3 Turns on them and 70k on them too. I took them to Napa to get resurfaced/turned and they said that they were okay but it was the last turn to do on them.
It could be a couple of things:
1. Double check the proper fit of the pad set itself. The pad model number should be printed on the back. Wouldn't be the first time that the wrong pads are in a mismarked box.
I bought them from Autozone and they fit just fine and are the 2nd set.
2. Make sure that the caliper in question has freely-moving pistons. Even one piston on a side stuck in the retracted state will allow a pad to move around, rattle, clunk, etc.
The both sides' inner pads move around about 1/8" and they are the source of all the noise I believe.
3. Verify that the caliper holes for the pad mounting pins are not deformed in any way allowing the pins excessive play. If they rattle around in those holes, you'll have noise.
Pins are new and they slide freely in the caliper holes but theyre snug in there I think?
4. Make sure that the wire pad separation springs are not fatigued. If these have been in service for some time, replacement might help the symptoms.
They're new as well but I dont think Autozone is the most trustworthy place for parts so I'm not sure.
5. Finally, make sure that you adequately lubed the inside of the caliper where the brake pads ride and the pad retention pins and corresponding mounting holes with a good application of high-temp brake grease.
I cleaned them out really well and regreased so I think they should be fine.
Don't get discouraged. Brake work is actually one of the most straightforward maintenance/repair functions we can do as an owner to save some serious money. You can make some simple, common mistakes though. Just takes practice.
Post back your results.